Christian Theology and US Politics: The Roots of MAGA Ideology

Chapter 2: Seeds of Resistance: The Religious Right's Origins in the Backlash to the New Deal

🌱 Chapter 2: Seeds of Resistance

The Religious Right's Origins in the Backlash to the New Deal

In the popular narrative of American politics, the rise of the Religious Right is often pinned to the social upheavals of the 1960s or the Moral Majority of the 1980s. But to truly understand the theological and ideological roots of today’s far-right political movements—particularly the MAGA-aligned fusion of Christian Nationalism and authoritarian populism—we need to rewind the tape to the 1930s. 📼

There, in the shadow of the Great Depression and Franklin D. Roosevelt’s sweeping New Deal programs, we find the earliest stirrings of a resistance that would one day morph into a full-blown theological-political insurgency. ⚔️

---

🏛️ The New Deal and the Birth of Christian Libertarianism

Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal aimed to stabilize a devastated economy, provide jobs and relief to suffering Americans, and regulate capitalism to prevent future collapses. 💼🧱

While it was largely popular among the public, the New Deal was met with fierce opposition from a coalition of business leaders, conservative politicians, and religious fundamentalists. To them, the expansion of federal power was not just an economic threat—it was a spiritual one. 🙏💣

Many conservative pastors and businessmen claimed that the welfare state was a form of idolatry that supplanted individual charity and faith in God with a dependence on secular government. 🏦✝️

A new strain of thought emerged: Christian libertarianism—a fusion of free-market capitalism with biblical principles, arguing that personal responsibility, individual liberty, and minimal government interference were divinely ordained. 📜💸

One of the key figures in this early movement was Rev. James W. Fifield Jr., a Congregationalist minister dubbed “The Apostle to Millionaires.” 💎 He preached a gospel of free enterprise and moral capitalism from the pulpit of his wealthy Los Angeles congregation and through his organization, Spiritual Mobilization. 📣

Fifield and his allies framed the New Deal as not just bad policy, but an existential threat to American Christianity. ⚠️✝️

---

⚖️ Setting the Stage for Theocracy

Though Christian Reconstructionism had not yet emerged, the seeds were being sown. 🌱

The backlash to the New Deal helped establish several critical precedents:

• ❌ Mistrust of "big government" as inherently anti-Christian

• 🏦 Fusion of conservative theology with capitalist economics

• 🏛️ Emerging alliances between corporate America and evangelical churches

• 🗣️ Use of Christian rhetoric to oppose civil rights, labor protections, and welfare programs

By the mid-20th century, these ideas were percolating in conservative Protestant seminaries, think tanks, and emerging media networks. 📡🧠

When social changes in the 1960s began to unsettle the status quo—civil rights ✊🏽, feminism 👩‍🎓, secularization 📚, and court decisions banning school prayer 🙏🚫—these earlier theological frameworks were ready to be deployed.

---

⛪ The Long Shadow of Calvinism

Many theologians and pastors who opposed the New Deal came from Reformed traditions, particularly those influenced by Calvinism. 🧠

With its emphasis on:

• Total depravity 😈

• Divine sovereignty 👑

• The supremacy of God's law 📖

Calvinism provided a theological foundation for later movements that would seek not just to influence politics but to reshape it entirely in the image of biblical authority. 🏛️✝️

This ideological lineage eventually found its most potent expression in the work of R.J. Rushdoony, a relatively unknown theologian at the time who would go on to found the Christian Reconstructionist movement in the 1960s and 1970s. 🧱

Rushdoony was deeply critical of both the New Deal and modern democracy, which he viewed as rebellions against God's law. ❌🗳️

---

🏗️ From Reaction to Blueprint

While conservative religious opposition to the New Deal was mostly reactive, Rushdoony and his successors would soon turn that reaction into a comprehensive blueprint for a theocratic society. 🏛️✝️📜

Movements such as:

• Christian Reconstructionism

• Dominion Theology

• Christian Zionism

would each emerge from—or alongside—these foundational beliefs. 🌉

They would branch out into distinct but overlapping strategies for reclaiming cultural and political dominance in the name of God. 🗳️✝️🔥

---

⏭️ Coming Up in Chapter 3...

In Chapter 3, we will examine how R.J. Rushdoony’s Christian Reconstructionism provided the intellectual foundation for this movement and laid the groundwork for the modern push toward a theocratic America. 🏛️🇺🇸✝️

Stay tuned. The theology is getting deeper—and so is the threat to democracy. 🕳️📉

Until next time, keep fighting the good fight.

Micky Shearon
The Blue Dot Dispatch

📍 Deep in the Heart of Red Texas

🚨 Follow & Subscribe: Blue Dot Dispatch on Substack
📣 Get Loud on Socials: Facebook | Blue Sky | TikTok | Instagram
💙 Because being a blue dot in a red state just means we shine brighter.

Get the e-book, “Christian Theology and US Politics: The Roots of MAGA Ideology” FREE by becoming a paid Subscriber to the Blue Dot Dispatch, or, you can purchase and download a copy here: https://payhip.com/b/scLSl